Skip to content
Denver Seminary
  • Apply
  • Visit
  • Request Info
  • Info for
    • Current Students
    • Alumni
    • Faculty/Staff Directory
  • The Gospel Initiative
  • About
    • Start Here
    • Who We Are
    • Faculty/Staff Directory
    • Accreditation
    • Our Campuses
    • Employment
    • History
    • Contact Us
    • Media Relations
  • Academics
    • View Programs
    • Fully Online Degrees
    • Program Delivery and Modality
    • Faculty
    • Clinical Pastoral Education Center
    • Library
    • Registrar
    • Training and Mentoring
    • Personal Formation
    • IDEAL Institute
    • Extension Seteca
    • 코리안 글로벌 캠퍼스
  • Admission & Aid
    • Start Here
    • Why Denver Seminary?
    • Admission Process
    • Important Dates
    • Enrollment Team
    • Financial Aid
    • Tuition and Fees
    • Visit
    • International Students
    • Student Housing
  • Resources
    • Start Here
    • Newsroom
    • Denver Counseling Center
    • Denver Journal
    • Engage Magazine
    • Engage360 Podcast
    • Events
    • Free Online Courses
    • Housing Board
    • In Perspective Panel Discussions
    • Initiatives
    • Job Board
  • Giving
    • Start Here
    • Give Now
    • Creative Giving
    • Advancement Team
    • President’s Annual Report

Denver Journal

  1. Home
  2. Journal
  3. Volume 25 - 2022
  4. Pascal: Reasoning and Belief
Back to Volume
Volume 1 - 1998
Volume 2 - 1999
Volume 3 - 2000
Volume 4 - 2001
Volume 5 - 2002
Volume 6 - 2003
Volume 7 - 2004
Volume 8 - 2005
Volume 9 - 2006
Volume 10 - 2007
Volume 11 - 2008
Volume 12 - 2009
Volume 13 - 2010
Volume 14 - 2011
Volume 15 - 2012
Volume 16 - 2013
Volume 17 - 2014
Volume 18 - 2015
Volume 19 - 2016
Volume 20 - 2017
Volume 21 - 2018
Volume 22 - 2019
Volume 23 - 2020
Volume 24 - 2021
Volume 25 - 2022
Volume 26 - 2023
Volume 27 – 2024
Volume 28 – 2025
Denver Journal Overview
Learn More about Denver Seminary Programs

Pascal: Reasoning and Belief

By: Michael Moriarty
Share
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
book cover reasoning and belief

Michael Moriarty, Pascal: Reasoning and Belief. New York: Oxford University Press, 2020. 413 pages with index. Hardback, $70.00. ISBN 978-0198849117

The French polymath, Blaise Pascal (1623-1662), is a source of fascination in several dimensions. He was a mathematician, scientist, a philosopher of science, and inventor of great genius, having invented the first calculating machine and the idea of mass transit. He experimentally proved that nature does not abhor a vacuum. He penned a rhetorical-polemical masterpiece, The Providential Letters, against the Jesuit’s laxity in moral theology. His writing style has been the subject of academic analysis, and he is considered a genius of French literature.

But Pascal was also a philosopher, and a good one, although he often is not given his due in histories of philosophy and elsewhere. Bertrand Russell dismisses him unfairly in A History of Western Philosophy (1945) and the most recent and much-used work, The Great Conversation by Norman Melchert and David Morrow mentions him but once in passing. When Pascal is given attention, it is sometimes limited to the wager argument and not put into a larger philosophical context of Pascal’s apologetic. As a Christian who had a profound experience of God known as “the night of fire,” Pascal wanted to articulate a sustained case for Christianity in an apologetic volume. However, he died before completing it. What he left has come to be called Pensées (or thoughts), plus a number of other writings related to commending the Christian faith. We are now in Michael Moriarty’s debt for offering the most comprehensive explanation and assessment of Pascal’s arguments for Christianity in recent memory. Professor Moriarty is Drapers Professor of French at the University of Cambridge and has published broadly in early modern French thought, including Early Modern French Thought.

Pascal: Reasoning and Belief is a comprehensive account of Pascal’s case for Christianity, focused mostly on Pensées. It is an intensely academic book, and not user-friendly unless one is an academic. All quotations of Pascal are first given in French, but then given by the author’s English translation. The print is small, the footnotes are many, the cost is expensive, and the page count is high. But for the avid Pascal scholar, the rewards are rich and varied.

Moriarty patiently addresses Pascal’s arguments (which are often given a sketchy form as notes or outlines of arguments), finds the most credible reading, and assesses them rationally. Nothing important is left or given short shrift in the twenty-one chapters of the book. While Moriarty shows a deep and serious appreciation for Pascal, he assesses each of Pascal’s argument by the merits and views them in light of his overall apologetic program. Moriarty takes all of Pascal’s apologetic arguments seriously, unlike some critics who take much of Pascal’s ideas to be beneath them or simply out of step with the times. For example, while Paul Griffith’s work, Why Read Pascal? ignores Pascal’s argument from prophecy on behalf of the supernatural nature of the Bible and the deity of Jesus, Moriarty addresses this in several places, although I think he gives the argument less credit that it deserves. The typical approach to his argument by Pascal is that modern scholarship has shown him to be naïve and pre-critical. So, the authors move on to other matters. However, the argument has been refined and profitably advanced by a number of scholars, such as Old Testament scholar, Walter Kaiser, in The Messiah of the Old Testament and, more recently, in Is Jesus of Nazareth the Predicted Messiah?: A Historical-Evidential Approach to Specific Old Testament Messianic Prophecies and Their New Testament Fulfillments by Douglas D. Scott.

The cost and density of this fine volume will prove prohibitive for many, but colleges, universities, and seminaries would do well to stock it in their libraries. Serious scholars of Pascal will find it a wealth of detailed analysis. I will give the author the last words of this review, which are the last words of his book. “Pascal cannot give his reader faith in the transformative power of the folly of the Cross; but he is one of the wise and the witnesses who might lead her to the verge of that faith” (394).

Douglas Groothuis, Ph.D.
Professor of Philosophy
Denver Seminary
July 20, 2022

Denver Seminary
  • 6399 South Santa Fe Drive
  • Littleton, Colorado, USA 80120
800.922.3040 info@denverseminary.edu

Locations
  • Denver
  • Washington DC Extension Site
  • Fully Online Degrees
Helpful Links
  • Request Information
  • Apply Now
  • Library
  • Denver Counseling Center
  • The Gospel Initiative
  • Legal Disclosures
  • Report a Concern

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn
  • Apply
  • Visit
  • Request Info
  • About
    • Start Here
    • Who We Are
    • Faculty/Staff Directory
    • Accreditation
    • Our Campuses
    • Employment
    • History
    • Contact Us
    • Media Relations
  • Academics
    • View Programs
    • Fully Online Degrees
    • Program Delivery and Modality
    • Faculty
    • Clinical Pastoral Education Center
    • Library
    • Registrar
    • Training and Mentoring
    • Personal Formation
    • IDEAL Institute
    • Extension Seteca
    • 코리안 글로벌 캠퍼스
  • Admission & Aid
    • Start Here
    • Why Denver Seminary?
    • Admission Process
    • Important Dates
    • Enrollment Team
    • Financial Aid
    • Tuition and Fees
    • Visit
    • International Students
    • Student Housing
  • Resources
    • Start Here
    • Newsroom
    • Denver Counseling Center
    • Denver Journal
    • Engage Magazine
    • Engage360 Podcast
    • Events
    • Free Online Courses
    • Housing Board
    • In Perspective Panel Discussions
    • Initiatives
    • Job Board
  • Giving
    • Start Here
    • Give Now
    • Creative Giving
    • Advancement Team
    • President’s Annual Report
  • Info for
    • Current Students
    • Alumni
    • Faculty/Staff Directory
  • The Gospel Initiative
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Please click the Accept button to acknowledge the use of cookies on our site.Accept